• Tag Archives land rover defender
  • Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender


    Overview

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042645

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042645

    In his latest video, YouTuber Sam CarLegion subjected these two potent off-roaders in a series of tug-of-war battles

    The contenders? Well, they’re amongst the best off-road rigs that are currently on sale, i.e popular Ford Bronco Badlands against the mighty Land Rover Defender P400. Let’s look at specs to see how these two top-tier off-roaders stack up against each other before they battle it over four rounds with their various off-road modes.

    2022 Ford Bronco Badlands

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042650

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042650

    In the grey corner, we’ve got the Ford Bronco Badlands, which features a 2.7 liter EcoBoost V-6, that produces 325 hp & 399 lb-ft of torque paired to a 10 speed auto box with 4WD

    In the grey corner, we have the popular Ford Bronco in Badlands spec. Under the hood lies a 2.7-liter turbo V-6 EcoBoost engine that produces 325 horsepower and 399 pound-feet of torque. The Bronco features a 10-speed automatic transmission with a four-wheel drive. The Badlands sits pretty much at the top of the Bronco range with only the Edition One doing one better.

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042651

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042651

    The Badlands pretty much sits at the top of the Bronco range and the one seen here is sitting on proper off-road tires. It can two about. It has a dedicated tow mode and cal haul 3500 lbs

    Ford designed it to be the ultimate off-roader with its GOAT mode system also including the rock crawl mode. You’ve got differential lockers on the Ford as well. The Bronco Badlands can tow 3500 pounds and tips the scales at 5320 pounds. The Badlands sits on 17-inch rims wrapped in proper 35 inch off-road tires.

    2022 Land Rover Defender P400

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042649

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042649

    In the blue corner, we have Land Rover’s latest generation P400 Defender that features a 3.0-liter inline-six, which produces 395 hp and 406 lb-ft of torque, mated to a 8 speed auto with AWD

    Next, in the blue corner, we have the latest generation of the Land Rover Defender P400 from across the pond. Under the hood lies a 3.0-liter turbocharged inline-six, that produces 395 horsepower and 406 pound-feet of torque. It is mated to an eight-speed auto box sending power to all four wheels.

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042636

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042636

    Unlike the previous old-school Defender, this latest model is loaded to the gills with a lot of high-tech off-road hardware like an electronic differential and Land Rovers legendary Terrain Response System. This particular example of the Defender can tow 8201 pounds and has a curb weight of 5035 pounds. The Defender comes wrapped in standard off-road tires with much larger rims.

    So having looked at the specs, the Defender has the higher horsepower and can tow more, but the Bronco is on proper off-road knobbly tires and even though it can tow lesser, it has a dedicated tow mode. Let’s see how things pan out in this tug-of-war.

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042647

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042647

    So on paper, the Defender has more power but can that compensate for the Broncos off-road tires on snow?

    Tug-Of-War: Land Rover Defender P400 vs Ford Bronco Badlands

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042648

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042648

    Well, lets find out as these two thoroughbreds go head to head over four rounds

    Both Sam, who is sat in the Bronco, and Richard in the Defender buckle up to battle out in a series of tug-of-wars lasting four rounds. For round one, they decide to do just have the SUVs in their 4×4 automatic mode.

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042644

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042644

    For round one, both SUVs are in their automatic 4WD modes. Both drivers take their foot off the brakes and gradually begin to apply pressure on the gas pedal

    With that, they take their foot off the brakes and begin to gradually hit the gas pedal. Well, despite the extra power on the Defender, it, unfortunately, began to spin its wheels and struggled to put those 395 ponies to the ground. The Bronco was had better traction and as a result, managed to pull the Defender to the other side. So that’s round one to the Badlands.

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042631

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042631

    For the second round, Richard in the Defender decides to engage his differential with low range and switches it up to the dedicated off-road mode. Will that make a difference? The short answer was no. It was more wheel spin for the Defender this time round as well.

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042633

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042633

    For the final two rounds, Sam has the Badlands set to its most extreme settings with traction off, both differential lockers activated with four-wheel low. It was no contest this time around and the Ford pulled the Defender well beyond the midway point. So the Bronco takes the final two rounds as well.

    Final Thoughts

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042665

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042665

    At the onset, we wanted to know if more power could compensate for better traction? Well, you have your answer. To sum it up, Sam says that they could do this all day long and it was the better tires that were helping the Bronco in this face-off.

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042646

    Tug Of War: Ford Bronco Badlands vs Land Rover Defender - image 1042646

    Now, although he feels that the Defender offers a far more refined on-road experience of the two, the Land Rover is more suited for a more mature audience. The Bronco meanwhile is most likely to be cheaper to both buy and run and he wouldn’t hesitate to give it some stick when he’s out with it in the elements.

    You can watch both off-roaders battle it out in Sam’s video below


  • Jaguar Land Rover Boss Talks Defender, Getting It Right

    2020 Land Rover Defender

    This interview should’ve been posted months ago.

    I sat with Jaguar Land Rover North America Product Planning Director Rob Filipovic at the 2020 Chicago Auto Show (remember those?) to talk about the reborn Defender.

    Then, I screwed up. I didn’t write the piece right away due to other work and travel. Still, the first drive was scheduled for mid-April, and I thought maybe the interview would work well as a companion piece to our first drive of the Defender.

    You know the rest.

    This week would’ve been the week in which the Detroit Auto Show took place in June for the first time. So in honor of that, I decided to publish my chat with Filipovic now.

    That’s not just a shout-out to a Detroit show that didn’t happen – as I wrote recently, the Defender is on sale now.

    Hard to get, perhaps, but on sale. So there’s news peg number two.

    Just to refresh your memory: the new Defender comes with either turbo-four or inline-six mild hybrid (turbocharged and supercharged) power under the hood (296 and 395 horsepower, respectively), and the design is a bit of a reimagining of the classic Defender’s boxy looks into a rounder, softer modernized version.

    I asked Filipovic how a brand brings back such an iconic vehicle that was so well-known, and well-loved, for being “old school” when today’s auto world doesn’t really allow for such no-frills/low-frills models. Even bare-bone vehicles are loaded up with mandated safety tech and convenience and comfort goodies that consumers, even those buying base models, demand.

    “I think the key is, for us, Defender was the genesis of the brand, effectively, if you go back all the way to the original concept. The biggest thing it always represented for us was, it is the most capable SUV,” Filipovic said.

    “The design and the capability need to be true to the original and the heritage of the brand, and kind of take them all to a new level. But then at the same time, the vehicle has to live up to what people expect in 2020 and beyond, as far as connectivity, functionality, comfort, and then overall quality as well.”

    I asked how JLR balances the off-road capability of the Defender against the likelihood that most owners will never take their Defender any further off-road than a gravel parking lot. We’ll see how things shake out, but I have a sneaking suspicion that Defenders will be seen more often in Chicago’s Gold Coast than at Moab – no matter how well the Defender can actually handle gnarly trails.

    It’s not just a question of usage versus capability – even Land Rovers that seem built for the street, like the Velar, can manage a rocky trail far from civilization. I know, because when Land Rover launched the Velar, I spent several hours in one on a California fire road in the desert outside Palm Springs. We got back in one piece.

    So, Land Rover will likely market the Defender based on what it can do off-road (hopefully we’ll get to experience that someday), but how does the brand manage the juxtaposition being its marketing and the behaviors of well-heeled buyers who would rather be seen on Rodeo Drive than on the Rubicon Trail?

    “That’s obviously a huge challenge, because I think, as you make something more and more capable off-road, traditionally, that [has] meant serious compromises with every other aspect of it, especially roll control, overall comfort over street surfaces, potholes and such. The big thing with Defender was it started its life off the platform that underpins Range Rover, Range Rover Sport, and Discovery. Which, I think, hopefully everyone would agree, that’s an extremely capable on-road platform, and extremely comfortable one.”

    He added, “From there, that platform was enhanced to deliver more off-road.”

    Filipovic credits the design – especially the short overhangs, along with the air suspension, the advent of adaptive suspensions, and the terrain management system – as key to the Defender’s potential.

    The brand’s product gurus, he said, asked themselves “how do we leverage technology, and design, to deliver what Defender needs to be off-road, but also give it really comfortable on-road feel?”

    Looking at pricing, the Defender overlaps on the low end with another vehicle that’s well-known, and certainly well-loved, for its off-road prowess. That’s the Jeep Wrangler. While top-end Defenders won’t be priced against feature-leaden Jeeps, there’s enough overlap that some cross-shopping between the two is possible, even likely.

    So I queried Filipovic – will the Defender be better on-road, and if so, will it be a selling point?

    Unsurprisingly, he suggested it would be better on-road – again, we’ll be the judge of whether he’s right once we drive one – and implied that it would a selling point. Again, ourselves, the rest of the automotive press, and the new-car buyer will be the ultimate judges of the first answer.

    A thornier question for JLR to answer is how can a new, luxed-up Defender that appeals to the high-end shopper also hold sway over the true trail rat who wants capability without frou-frou and frills?

    “I think it just depends on what Defender do you want?”, he said. He mentioned the rubberized floor, which in theory should be easy to clean after a day of muddin’, and talked about the spread of Defender trims. So, mudders, the base model might be best for you. Filipovic said 10-20 percent of Land Rover customers go off-roading, and he expects the percentage of Defender buyers who plan to go off-road will be a “step higher”, though he didn’t give a specific number.

    I had to ask about #savethemanuals, and the answer was the same I’ve heard for so many models: The take-rate is projected to be just too damn low to justify the cost.

    He doesn’t expect the Defender name to carry much weight with non-car-folk, but did say he thinks the design might catch shoppers’ eyes, even if they don’t know about the Defender’s past.

    He didn’t have specific numbers available for hand-raisers back in February, but he mentioned that consumer Web site traffic has been at an all-time high, along with the use of build configurators.

    I pressed him on future electrification plans beyond the mild-hybrid powertrain and got the usual response about future products: “Stay tuned.” There are no plans for off-road motorsports right now, though.

    With Defender and Ford’s off-road-oriented Bronco on the way, Filipovic says he thinks of the segment as more than a niche, because, according to JLR’s internal research, Defender is drawing interest from everywhere.

    Finally, we closed with a sore subject for JLR, one I’ve experienced firsthand – quality. He mentioned a simplified infotainment system and over-the-air updates as examples of how the brand is addressing quality. Still, he knows there is work to be done.

    “The proof is in the delivery. We’ve got to continue to kind of improve quality over and over again.”

    [Image: Jaguar Land Rover]